Vincent Boyer is among the most talented of our winemakers, and his family owns some the Côte d’Or’s finest white wine terroir. It’s a powerful combination: today all of his wines are best in class, from the humble aligoté to the gorgeous premier crus from Meursault and Puligny-Montrachet. Since he took over winemaking more than a decade ago, the Domaine Boyer-Martenot’s star has risen steadily. Many would be content with the renown he has achieved, but Vincent is an innovator. In 2017 he began acquiring cement eggs that have allowed him to lengthen his finest wines’ elevage from 12 to 20 months. It was a great idea. Twenty months in oak barrels might well have brought too much oxygenation, but the eggs allow extra time on the lees without continuing micro-oxygenation. The result is even more complexity than before.
Vincent Boyer makes the best Aligoté we have ever seen. This humble grape, Burgundy’s “other white,” often struggles to ripen and has an acid spine that’s difficult to tame. Most Burgundians solve this by using it in Kir, a delicious apéritif in which Crème de Cassis is added to soften it up. Vincent Boyer transforms Aligoté by barrel fermentation into a delicious wine that is round and smooth, though relatively inexpensive. His 2018 Aligoté is lovely — floral and golden with nice sucrosité and well-balanced freshness. It requires no Cassis (though it’s a delicious pair too). His Bourgogne Chardonnay similarly punches above its weight, benefiting from 20 months of élévage and his superb technique. It won’t have the exceptional character of his wines from the great terroirs, but it shows touches of refinement rarely seen in a Bourgogne — a hint of spice, a touch of mineral, and a lingering finish.
Meursault is a remarkably diverse terroir, unified by its clay-limestone soils but offering a wide range of subsoils and even wider range of elevations. The vineyards at the top of the slope lie 500 feet above those at the base — a very large spread. There is, of course, a typicity to Meursault’s wines, and anyone who knows them will speak readily of their opulence. But more than most villages there is a broad range of nuance.
In 2018s, we are offering two village Meursaults that illustrate the contrasts in the appellation’s terroir. From the upper part of the slope there is Narvaux, normally a clean and precise wine that is always listed among Meursault’s best village-level vineyards. Ormeau is stylistically opposite, in the village itself and on flat, clay-rich ground. It offers what people most often expect from Meursault — a rich and round wine with plenty of gras (fat). We like Narvaux best in the riper years, which knock off any sharp edges while leaving the beautiful complexity that is its signature; and for us 2018 is among the best of those ripe years. Narvaux’s balance in 2018 is just magnificent. (Burghound agreed, calling it “outstanding” and “very Meursault.”) On the other hand, if your taste runs to opulent wine, consider what comes from Ormeau’s nearly hundred-year-old vines. There is richness and sucrosité along with flavors that Burghound called “ample, rich, and caressing,” and “a seductive mouthfeel.” Lush, ripe, old-school Meursault.
Meursault has nineteen premier crus, but three are universally considered the best: Charmes, Genevrières, and Perrières. Wine writer Rajat Parr characterizes them thus: “Perrières — the eternal Grand Cru in waiting, with its epic fusion of body and minerality, frame and physique; Charmes — full bodied and physical, but deep and engaging; and Genevrieres — crystalline in structure, at once gossamer and formidable.” Vincent Boyer makes wine in all three — and as if that weren’t enough, he’s also one of only 5 owners of “En Cailleret,” one of Puligny’s finest premier cru vineyards. In 2018, as usual, it’s simply impossible to go wrong.
Charmes 1er cru 2018 is classic Meursault: rich, round and generous on the palate, with exotic and enticing perfume on the nose. Burghound gave 90-92 points, finding “citrus blossom, pear, apple and a hint of hazelnut.” It will drink well from the time it arrives in your cellar. Meursault 1er cru Genevrières was terrific last year, but the 2018 may be even better. The nose is more serious, less floral, and more precise. The depth and fullness are astonishing — Burhound cited its “intensity” and “impressively voluminous flavors.” Meursault 1er cru Perrieres offers minerality and tension on a highly concentrated base. It needs some time to develop its great complexity, but when it gets there it can be something to behold. Burghound awarded 91-93 points, calling it “utterly delicious” and “outstanding.”
We much enjoyed a recent brief video in which Dominique Lafon of Meursault’s Domaine Comtes Lafon discussed his village. [Link here.] In a few well-chosen words, Lafon highlights the signatures of Meursault’s best known vineyards, and then inadvertently (we think) gives up his personal favorite when he discusses Genevrieres. There is palpable enthusiasm as he describes “the most elegant wine produced in Meursault.”
Vincent Boyer also owns excellent plots in the neighboring village of Puligny-Montrachet: Reuchaux at the village level, and En Cailleret at premier cru. Puligny needs more time to show well than does Meursault — these are normally wines of tension and precision and require time in a quiet cellar to round out and integrate. Reuchaux 2018 will drink well a bit earlier than some vintages, but some patience is wise nonetheless. The balance of serious mineral and saline notes with perfectly clean fruit is extraordinary — it calls to mind Jay McInerney’s description of Puligny as the “Grace Kelly of wine.”. Burghound found notes of “citrus peel and essence of pear and apple compote,” calling it “delicious.” About this time next year it should begin to be excellent.
Boyer-Martenot’s plot in Puligny 1er cru “En Cailleret” is remarkable. Cailleret adjoins the great Grand Cru Montrachet to the south, and the Boyer family is one of just five vintners who own vines there. It is a wine of great intensity whose aromatic complexities reveal themselves only after a few years. Today an extraordinarily long finish marks its likely greatness. Burghound awarded 91-93 points, calling it “outstanding” and citing “intensity and precision” with a “chiseled finish.” His suggested drinking window begins in 2028, but we won’t fault you for trying a bottle in 2024.
BOYER-MARTENOT
(case prices)
Aligoté 2018: $225
Bourgogne blanc 2018: $350
Meursault “Ormeau” 2018: $725
Meursault “Narvaux” 2018: $725
Meursault 1er “Charmes” 2018: $1,095
Meursault 1er “Genevrières” 2018: $1,195
Meursault 1er “Perrières” 2018: $1,295
Puligny-Montrachet “Reuchaux” 2018: $825
Puligny-Montrachet 1er “Cailleret” 2018: $1,495